XS Sights, yes or no?

A while back I talked about XS Sights, and how I don’t particularly see the point in them as a sighting system for pistols.  Here’s the problem though – quite a few people I respect are of a divided opinion on XS Sights.  For example, Todd Green says “no”, Richard Mann and Michael Bane like them, and from the world of fiction, Owen Pitt from the Monster Hunter novels used them on his Kimber before it was destroyed by vampires in Monster Hunter International.

So, what are your thoughts?  I’m going to take the opportunity to eat crow on the XS Sight issue, as the 686SSR I own has an interchangeable front sight blade.   I’d love to hear your feedback on the sights, and because I feel bad for badmouthing them without giving  them a fair shake, I’ve ordered a set for my 686SSR that I’m going to shoot in ICORE and IDPA.  If I like them and find them fast and accurate, I’ll happily retract any naughty things I’ve said about them.  And, in the interest of full disclosure, I’m actually paying for the sights – no freebies on this one.

Indiana State IDPA Championship

Put my entry for the Indiana State IDPA Championship in the mail today.  I’ll be shooting Enhanced Service Revolver again this year with my S&W 625.  I’m pretty excited about this match this year.  It’s been bumped up to June from October in previous years, which (hopefully) means we won’t be shooting in the soggy rain or the freezing cold.  Last year, I shot the match in pouring rain, and the year before (shooting in ESP) I shot it in 30 degree weather.  I joked with one of the other shooters at last year’s match that “just once” we’d like to shoot it warm and dry.

Hopefully this June will be our chance to shoot it warm and dry!  Once I get back from my leave of absence, I should have about a month to practice for the match by running myself through various IDPA stages and preparing for the major.  I’m also hoping to shoot the Indiana USPSA Sectionals this year using the same gun and load – can’t get too much trigger time.

So fast you miss

ToddG talks about speed in pistol shooting, and it’s certainly worth a read.  The main point he’s trying to make is that once you’ve mastered “smooth” in pistol shooting so that you can safely draw, load, etc with control over the firearm that if you want to get faster, you have to practice going fast.  It’s tremendously useful to find out just how fast you can go, and sometimes you need to go so fast that you don’t get the hits you’d want to get.  Todd says “don’t spray the backstop with lead”, what he’s talking about is shooting a -3 instead of a -1, or a -1 instead of a -0 on an IDPA target.

Here’s a good example – the IDPA classifier.  The first three strings of fire are two body shots and one head shot from the holster on each of the three targets.  I shot  the first string in 2.23 seconds with my 686SSR…but I missed the head shot.  Sent it right over the target at 7 yards.  That was useful in establishing my upper band for speed – I knew that if I tried to go that fast, I’d probably miss.  So I dialed it back a little bit for my next two strings, getting all my hits in 2.93 and 2.45 respectively.  I didn’t back all the way down to a +3 second time, because I knew I could stay around 2.5 seconds and get the hits.

That’s the benefit of practicing for speed – you actually get faster!  Of course, you do still need to practice for accuracy and trigger control.  Regular practice should be a combination of practicing for accuracy, speed, or a combination of both.  But it’s absolutely true that you can’t get faster unless you actually practice going faster.

Dan Burton on Gun Nuts Radio

Did you miss last night’s Gun Nuts Radio featuring Congressman Dan Burton? It was a great show, which you should check out it if you’re interested any of the following topics: gun control, health care legislation, why is Nancy Pelosi so crazy, the Navy SEALs being court-martialed, and many more. Click here for the show or click here for a portable .mp3 file of the show.

The show is also available on Gun Nuts Host - Gun Nuts Radio: The Next Generation of Shooting | Blog Talk Radio Feed - Gun Nuts Radio: The Next Generation of Shooting | Blog Talk Radio Feed by clicking the handy button as well, or you can always click here to go to the download page.

In sad news, last night’s Gun Nuts Radio was the last show that I’m going to do for about a month. I’m taking a month long leave of absence from both the show and the blog effective Saturday to attend to a major career opportunity that has come my way. The last two years of hosting Gun Nuts Radio have been great, and I want to thank everyone for their support of the show and the blog.

Don’t forget to check out Dan Burton on last night’s show, and keep an eye on the website for our return in a month to a new format, new direction, and more awesomeness on Gun Nuts Radio!

Why standards are important

The good ol’ IDPA Classifier Match has been getting some screen time this past week in a couple of places, and the usual emails and comments have come up about why the classifier exists, why it doesn’t reflect what IDPA has become, etc etc.  I’ve actually gone back and forth on classifier on whether or not I liked it, but in the last couple of years I’ve really come around to seeing the value of the classifier match for not just IDPA shooters, but anyone interested in building their defensive gunhandling skills.

First, let’s look at what the IDPA classifier isn’t.  It is not a reflection of what IDPA is at the club or national match level.  Despite the intentions of the IDPA Founding Fathers, IDPA has effectively become IPSC-Light with lower round count stages and a slightly different rule set.  This has been driven by the people that actually shoot IDPA at the competitive national level as there’s been a gradual shift towards a more “action” oriented sport.  This isn’t a bad thing in my opinion, but the classifier doesn’t really reflect the sport IDPA has become.

I’m totally okay with that though, because what the classifier does represent is an objective standard.  It’s 90 rounds, with the same three stages that it’s had for years and years, which means that the classifier can be used as a tool to gauge your progress as a marksman and competitor against a measurable, quantifiable standard.  I’ll use my progress as an example:  the first time I shot the classifier, I was shooting a ParaUSA P16-40 Limited.  That particular .40 S&W 1911 style pistol is classified in Enhanced Service Pistol division.  Shooting the classifier for the first time three years ago, I shoot the entire match with a total time of 126.44, which put me in the Sharpshooter division.  Earlier this year, I shot the exact same match, the same 90 round course of fire using a Smith & Wesson 625 revolver in .45 ACP.  My total time?  97.61 seconds, fast enough for Enhanced Service Revolver Master class.

That’s the first value of the classifier match – periodically re-shooting the classifier is a good way to bench mark your skills and see if you’re improving.  Going from an easily shootable 1911 and running the course 30 seconds faster with a DA revolver indicates that I’ve managed to figure something out that I’m doing right.

The second value of the IDPA classifier is that it’s good practice without being too expensive.  Say you’ve only got 100 rounds to practice with since times are tight.  In the course of 90 of those rounds, you will have reloaded on the clock 4 times, practiced shooting on the move both forward and retreating, Mozambique drills, El Presidente, shooting from cover, shooting from a kneeling position, and moving to a different shooting position.  I’m not saying that all you should practice is the IDPA classifier, but when mixed in with other drills and shooting practices, it is a good way to practice the fundamentals of action and defensive shooting without burning up a ton of ammo.

The third thing the classifier helps me do is identify problem areas with my shooting.  For example, I just shot the classifier on Sunday with Tam as mentioned, and while I turned in a smokin’ fast raw time, my points down were waaaaay too high and I missed master-class in Stock Service Revolver.  From reviewing my scores, I can see that my problems occurred primarily on the 3rd stage.  My accuracy wasn’t where it needed to be at 20 yards, so I need to work on my long distance shooting.  Practice long, tight shots will help my classifier scores and my overal skill.

Standards in shooting are just like good record keeping in physical fitness.  If I do 50 pushups on Monday, and then Monday a month later I do 75 pushups, I know I’ve had 50% increase in the strength necessary to do pushups.  It’s the same with standards – you can measure your progress against objective standards and identify problem areas with your shooting.

Congressman Dan Burton on Gun Nuts Radio tonight!

Tonight on Gun Nuts Radio at 9pm Eastern time I’m extremely pleased to welcome Congressman Dan Burton of Indiana to the show.  Congressman Burton will be joining us tonight to discuss his re-election bid and the tough primary fight he’s in; we’ll also be discussing his advocacy on behalf of the three Navy SEALs facing court martial, gun laws at the national and Indiana level, and of course getting the Congressman’s thoughts on governmental over-spending, health care reform, and other topics.  If you have a question you’d like me to ask the Congressman, please email it to me at gunnutsradio@gmail.com and I’ll read your question on the air.

That’s tonight at 9pm Eastern time on the BlogTalkRadio Network at www.blogtalkradio.com/gunnuts – join us!

Big Business trying to kill HB 1065!

As you know, HB 1065 passed the Indiana House and Senate and is headed to Governor Daniels’ desk for his signature.  In a last minute desperation move, Big Business lobbyists are using Friday’s shooting at an Indiana Department of Workforce Development in Portage to try and lobby the Governor’s office to veto the bill.  This is a desperate act by a group of lobbyists unconcerned with the rights of law-abiding gun owners to get Gov. Daniels to veto a good bill that protects Indiana citizens.

The problem though is that the Big Business lobby is twisting the facts of what happened in Portage to suit their agenda: they’re saying that passage of this bill will cause more shootings like the one on friday, when anyone with half a brain knows that’s a complete fabrication.  The fact is that the passage of HB 1065 will help protect Hoosiers – imagine you’re walking to your car when this maniac opens fire, and he decides that you’re a convenient target of opportunity.  Right now, and if Big Business gets their way, you would be unarmed and facing a deranged man with a shotgun.

If HB 1065 passes, law-abiding citizens would have the right to keep their legally owned firearms in their vehicles, giving them a fighting chance if another maniac like this decides to break the law and try to murder innocent people.

Don’t let Big Business trample your rights!  Contact Governor Mitch Daniels today and urge him to pass HB 1065 so that law abiding citizens of Indiana can protect themselves!

Why we win

Because people will fly three hours from Japan (where you can’t own guns) to a US Territory for Shooting Vacations.  Guns are cool.

IDPA Stock Service Revolver

I shot the IDPA classifier match yesterday with Tam which by itself would have been worth a post or two, but I was also shooting my Smith & Wesson 686SSR for the first time as well.  I wanted to get classified in Stock Service Revolver Division for the upcoming IDPA season as well as get some trigger time on the gun I’m planning on shooting in ICORE’s Retro Division.  The gun itself is a 4 inch Smith & Wesson 686 with a slab sided barrel, red ramp front sight (more on that later), wood stocks, chamfered charge holes, a trigger overtravel stop, and generally a pretty nice double action trigger pull.  The single action trigger breaks around 4 pounds – that’s pretty much irrellevant though, because this gun won’t have a single action mode for much longer.

I shot the classifier using my Blade-Tech holster, which interestingly enough fits my N-frame revolvers and this smaller L-frame.  For speedloaders, I used the nearly ubiquitous HKS style speedloaders instead of the more “competition” popular Comp-III loaders.  The reason for this is that I discovered I was having the occasional “yard sale” with the Comp-III loaders.  Since I first started shooting a wheelgun with a moonclip gun, my desire is to grab the speedloader as close to the main body of the loader, aka the part where the bullets are. When doing this with a Comp-III loader, I’d sometimes hit the release at the top of the loader and fling my rounds all over the planet.  Loading with the HKS loaders is very similar to loading with a moonclip.  You grab the loader by the black part, not the silver knob, drop the whole loader into the cylinder then twist the knob and flick the loader away.  In practice I can hit a 3.5 second reload using this method, and on the range I averaged about 4 seconds on reloads.  Not great, but not terrible all things considered.

The actual classifier match didn’t go poorly, although I dropped way too many points on the 7 yard stage because I was pushing too hard for speed.  The first three strings on the classifier are all 2 shots to the body and one to the head from the holster.  My average time for those strings was 2.56 seconds, which is great…except that I dropped a head shot on the first target!  You can’t do that at 7 yards and expect to still make Master class, and I didn’t.  While my raw time was smoking fast, coming in at 86.23 for shots fired, I had to add 23 seconds(!) for points down, putting my overall classifier score at 114.23.  That’s good enough for Expert class, which I should be happy with, but I know I can shoot better.

But how did the gun do?  Just fine.  Despite shooting smoky CCI Blazer lead ammo, extraction stayed positive and rounds continued to drop into the gun pretty handily.  The only part of the gun I’m not really in love with is the red ramped front sight.  I generally prefer post sights on my guns, and the red ramp sight is huge, I mean absurdly huge.  At 20 yards, the front sight basically obscures the entire target, and the rear notch doesn’t let a whole lot of light in around the front sight.  I’ll probably end up switching out the front sight for something a little faster that shows a little more light on the sides of the post.  Other than that, I’m completely pleased with this gun.  For a gun I’d never fired before, going out and shooting Expert on the IDPA classifier is pretty cool – I’ll just need to practice more!

Note: The S&W 686SSR was provided to me as a Testing and Evaluation gun by Smith & Wesson.  At the end of the T&E period I liked it so much I decided to buy it instead of returning it.

Guns in Parking lots fight not over yet

And I don’t just mean in my comments – here’s the release from our friends at NRA:

Indiana: Emergency Powers/Workplace Protection Headed to the Governor, but the fight is not over!

Please Contact your legislator and local rural electric company!

As House Bill 1065 passed in the Indiana State House on Thursday, March 4, several groups began attempts to undermine NRA efforts by amending other bills still alive in the General Assembly to water down the NRA legislation. Leading the charge are the Indiana State Chamber of Commerce and the Indiana Rural Electric Association, who unsuccessfully attempted to amend an omnibus bill, HB 1086, which would have diluted the language already headed to the Governor’s desk. Their amendment would have made sweeping exceptions to the prohibition on employers from firing employees who safely and lawfully store their firearms in their privately-owned locked vehicles while on an employer’s property. HB 1065 already contains exemptions for Chemical and nuclear facilities deemed to be significant homeland security risks, power-generating electric facilities, schools, child care centers, and domestic violence shelters. The Rural Electric and Chamber strategy is to add further exemptions to neuter the intent of the legislation. The NRA fairly and competently negotiated the exemptions and those attempting to add to the exemptions did not adequately justify their desire to further erode our second Amendment Rights.

Please contact your legislator now and respectfully request they oppose any attempt to change the Emergency Powers/Workplace Protection Act. Also call your local rural electric company to urge their association to stop their attempts to trample on your Second Amendment rights!

Let’s make sure that attempts to water this bill down by the Democrats in the Indiana house fail!